There is trouble brewing in the Love Soup Kitchen, as Fair Go's Matt Chisholm discovers.
By Matt Chisholm
Saturday morning at the market. I bite the bullet, line up and buy one. It's a delicious, piping-hot, wee taste of home, but boy do I feel guilty. Not guilty enough to stop at one, though. I go back for a second. Then a third.
I've read the headlines. Read the entire stories. Whitebait are being wiped out because of people like me. They could soon be gone forever - and it's my fault. Or is it?
According to a Department of Conservation report released last year, three of the five whitebait species are "at risk/declining" and one species is "threatened".
Everyone agrees humans are having a huge impact on whitebait habitat, but people don't agree on how much of an impact fishing has on these species.
To help protect these native fish Forest and Bird are calling for recreational catch limits and a complete commercial ban on whitebaiting.
"Here is a species that are in trouble and there's no limit at all to the amount that you can catch" says Forest and Bird's Kevin Hague.
But Dr Mike Hickford, a marine ecologist at the University of Canterbury says fears of wiping out whitebait are grossly overblown. "I don't think we will ever wipe out whitebait" he says.
Hickford says a distinction needs to be made between adult and the post-larvae fish. "There's no doubt that the adult stage of these fish are in trouble, but it doesn't translate to the whitebait".
Hickford says there's no evidence to suggest at this stage that whitebaiting affects the threatened adult population, which spawn in such huge numbers.
"The majority of those whitebaits that are coming back in to the river, they're going to die anyway, they always have died and they still will die in the future no matter what we do".
Despite a lack of clear evidence, Kevin Hague says restrictions on how we catch whitebait, how much we can catch and the sale of whitebait should be introduced before the start of next 3-month long season (Sept-Nov).
"We don't want to interfere with someone's ability to go and get a feed for their family, but we just think there should be some tools that we use to actually reduce the pressure on these species".
Cascade Whitebait, one of New Zealand's biggest commercial whitebaiters, fish each season on the isolated Cascade river, just south of Haast.
Nan Brown, whose parents helped set up the operation 70 years ago, says their records don't show any decline in whitebait catch. She wants to hold on to their fishery and says, "It would be unfair to let the guillotine drop on something you don't know enough about.”
Watch the full story tomorrow night AT 7.30pm on SUNDAY TVNZ1 or TVNZOnDemand